Project Runway--Season 4

Janee · Sawyer Brook Staff Joined: 05 Apr 2007 Posts: 72

I would have had a really hard time judging those 3 - I loved Jillian's knitwear, Rami's garments were beautiful but I wasn't crazy about the colors. I do think they were right in choosing Christian's collection as the winner, although I would have liked to see less black in it! I think he really benefitted from having Victoria Beckham there as a judge - they do appear to be on the same fashion page!

I had a really interesting night, as I also watched the PR finale from season 3 earlier - I've been watching it on DVD and just happened to be at that point. There was so much more tension and rivalry last year, with the accusation from Laura about Jeffrey not doing his own sewing. This year's contestants really appeared to be more friendly with one another!

zigzagger · Joined: 07 Jun 2007 Posts: 54 Location: Massachusetts

I think all the collections were good, it was definitely a tough choice. I think that they maybe picked Christian because he has his whole life ahead of him, and no money. Rami is my favorite, but he is forty and has a storefront workspace. And Jillian doesn't seem to really need the money, although her designs were good too.